The Paleo Diet is a diet plan for people looking to eat a hunter-gatherer diet that emphasizes the way humans used to eat.
The idea behind it is that our ancestors used to eat foods that were more wholesome, and because of this they had better overall health.
The main focus of this diet is to emphasize:
You can read many different books and websites that outline the basics of this diet. It’s unlike other plans as it’s more about eating natural foods, as opposed to specific macronutrients and micronutrients.
While it’s not specifically for weight loss, the diet plan emphasizes that overall health will be improved. So by the virtue of eating better foods, your body will be able to regulate itself. Therefore, you’re likely not to be overweight.
Some foods that are emphasized include:
More of an emphasis is placed on what’s not allowed:
One benefit to this diet according to the website PaleoLeaps is that:
“Calorie counting is not encouraged, neither is portion control”
This can make it easy to eat all the types of foods allowed on this diet. You basically eat as you’d like without having to restrict yourself to weighing foods on a scale.
However, not all paleo diet supports can agree on whether or not you should limit carbohydrates. Some argue that depending on the type of hunter-gatherer background, one would be allowed more plants, which will are known to provide carbohydrates. Other websites that offer advice are stricter, and they claim high animal protein and low carbohydrate are essential.
Scientific American presented one argument against this diet. They mention that a 1990 anthropological study into the Hiwi tribe showed that these hunter gatherers:
“are not particularly healthy”
“are shorter, thinner, more lethargic, and less well nourished.”
“men and women of all ages constantly complain of hunger”
This is from a tribe whose diets consist of 95% foods that would be considered strict paleo. Therefore, it’s not the best decision to change to a fully paleo lifestyle. Those who are forced to live this don’t have the best overall health, and they’re also malnourished.
Also, another distinguishing factor is whether or not the diet allows for some types of dairy. Some argue that full fat unprocessed milk and cheese is paleo, though other sites won’t allow this.
This is one of the great issues with this diet. Not every site agrees on whether or not you should eat certain foods, or how much of a split if any, is required for the amounts of proteins, carbohydrates, and fats.
It’s fairly simple, you eat like a caveman used to while avoiding processed foods like cereal, grains, sugars, and anything that’s not traditionally eaten by our ancestors.
One tricky thing about this diet is eating out. Since you’re not allowed salt, vegetable oils, processed dairy, and other processed foods, you have to be careful about how your food is prepared. This means you either have to ask your server for specific alterations, or you have to prep all your meals from whole unprocessed foods.
Many prepackaged foods even if they’re paleo foods, can be prepped with things like salt.
According to Kathleen Zelman, a registered dietician, this diet:
“may be a tough plan to follow long term due to dietary limits and restrictions”
The problem with eating like our ancestors used to, is that now, these types of foods can be costly. It’s often advised to only eat foods which are grass fed, wild caught, or organic. This significantly raises the overall price.
The Leiden University Medical Centre performed one study into the diet:
“None of the RCTs evaluated an improvement in quality of life”
The Quarterly Review of Biology also performed an analysis, which showed that carbohydrates were incredibly beneficial to human health. The study showed that:
“cooked starch, a source of preformed glucose, greatly increased energy availability to human tissues”
It also showed a remarkable improvement in brain health. According to this landmark 2015 study, carbohydrates were directly responsible for the growth of the human brain.
This is why glucose, which is found in carbohydrates, is the main fuel source to the brain. It’s also a great post-workout food, as it quickly delivers support to the muscles.
All this information means that the idea of a paleo diet is flawed. Since, starches and legumes are actually quite healthy and not a bad thing to add to your diet in moderation.
This diet can be really demanding. The main issue being that not only will your grocery bills likely go up, but also there’s no scientific evidence to support the idea that you should avoid the non-paleo friendly foods.
New science in genetics shows that many people can now enjoy dairy and grains while gaining many benefits.
Scientific American studied this diet and they add:
“the Paleo Diet is founded more on privilege than logic”
“Which hunter-gatherer tribe are we supposed to mimic?”
The major issue not yet explained is whether or not you should follow a paleo diet according to the Inuit, Hiwi, Kung, Hadza or other tribes. Each one had access to different type of foods. For some it was heavy on meats, other’s had less access and eat more veggies and nuts.
It’s for this reason why this diet has not yet been proven to be an effective diet plan.
There’s both good and bad things allowed by this diet. Eating less processed foods will always be a good solution for overall health and weight loss.
Making sure you eat more natural foods from the earth is always a better solution. However, the idea that you can just eat as much as you want is not a proper way to lose weight. Calories can accumulate very quickly, and making sure you stay under a certain amount of calories is necessary for weight loss.
Also, the paleo diet is flawed, there are too many hunter-gatherer tribes that ate completely different kinds of foods. Another problem is that the body has adjusted o eating grains and dairy, there’s no proof to suggest these are bad for everyone.
Better diet plans exist that don’t require you to limit yourself as much as the paleo diet requires.
Receive a Weekly Newsletter from CGH